Newfields, NH Electrical Troubleshooting & Repair Guide

Estimated Read Time: 10 minutes

A flickering light, a crackling switch, or a fixture that will not turn on can point to a bad switch. This easy DIY guide shows you how to replace a faulty light switch step by step, including safety checks and wiring basics. If anything looks unusual or you have aluminum wiring, call a licensed electrician. Keep reading, then use our coupon if you decide to have us handle it for you.

Tools and Materials You Will Need

Gather these before you start. Having everything ready keeps the job safe and tidy.

1. Non-contact voltage tester
2. Flathead and Phillips screwdrivers
3. Needle-nose pliers and wire strippers
4. Replacement switch rated for your circuit
5. • Single-pole, three-way, or a compatible dimmer
5. Electrical tape
6. Flashlight or headlamp
7. Replacement wall plate
8. Optional: Short lengths of 14 or 12 AWG copper wire and wire connectors

Pro tip: Match the switch to the circuit amperage and your wiring gauge. Most lighting is on 15-amp circuits with 14 AWG wire. If you see 12 AWG wire on a 15-amp breaker, that is still acceptable. Never install a 20-amp device on a 15-amp circuit.

Safety First: Power Off and Test

Your first step is always to kill power at the breaker.

1. Identify the correct breaker for the light circuit.
2. Turn the breaker fully to OFF. Place a piece of tape over it so no one flips it back on.
3. Remove the wall plate and switch screws. Gently pull the switch forward.
4. Use a non-contact voltage tester on the wires and the switch screws. Confirm no voltage.

If your tester shows any voltage or you feel unsure, stop here and call a licensed electrician. Signs of trouble include brittle insulation, melted plastic, scorch marks, or a burning smell. If you see aluminum wiring, do not proceed. Aluminum requires special connectors and methods.

Identify Your Switch Type

Before you disconnect anything, note how the existing switch is wired. Take a clear photo. Then match it to one of these types.

Single-Pole Switch

• Controls one light from one location.
• Has two terminal screws plus a green ground screw.
• One hot feed and one switched leg.

Three-Way Switch

• Controls one light from two locations, like at the top and bottom of stairs.
• Has three terminal screws: one dark-colored common and two brass travelers, plus a green ground.
• No ON or OFF label, since either position can turn the light on.

Dimmer or Smart Switch

• Must be rated for the fixture type: LED, incandescent, or mixed load.
• Many electronic dimmers need a neutral. Check the instructions and your box. Older homes may not have a neutral in the switch box.

Step-by-Step: Replace a Single-Pole Light Switch

Follow these steps for a standard on-off switch.

1. Verify Power Is Off
2. • Test the switch body and each wire with your non-contact tester.
2. Disconnect Wires
3. • Loosen the side screws. If the wires are backstabbed, release them using the release slot or cut and re-strip.
3. Prepare the New Switch
4. • Identify the green ground screw and the two brass terminals.
4. Connect the Ground
5. • Attach the bare or green wire to the green screw. Tighten firmly.
5. Connect the Hot and Switched Leg
6. • Attach one black wire to one brass screw and the other black wire to the remaining brass screw. Orientation does not matter for a single-pole.
   • Make a clockwise hook on each stripped wire end so it wraps under the screw head. Tighten until snug.
6. Secure and Insulate
7. • Lightly wrap electrical tape around the switch body to cover side terminals. This reduces accidental contact in tight boxes.
7. Reinstall
8. • Fold wires back neatly. Do not pinch. Mount the switch level. Install the wall plate.
8. Restore Power and Test
9. • Turn the breaker ON and test the switch. The light should toggle properly. If it trips a breaker, turn it off and recheck connections.

Step-by-Step: Replace a Three-Way Switch

Three-way switches have one common and two travelers. Correctly placing the common wire is the key.

1. Label Before Removal
2. • With power OFF, find the dark screw on the old switch. That terminal is the common. Label the wire connected to it with tape.
2. Remove the Old Switch
3. • Gently pull the switch out. Note which wires are on the two traveler screws.
3. Prepare the New Three-Way Switch
4. • Identify the dark common screw and the two brass traveler screws, plus the green ground.
4. Connect Wires
5. • Attach the labeled common wire to the dark screw.
   • Attach the remaining two traveler wires to the brass screws. Either traveler can go on either brass screw.
   • Connect the ground wire to the green screw.
5. Install and Test
6. • Mount the switch, install the plate, restore power, and test from both locations. If the light only works in one combination, the travelers may be crossed in the other switch box. Check both ends.

Dimmer and Smart Switch Notes

• Always use a dimmer that lists LED compatibility if you have LED bulbs. Old dimmers can cause flicker.
• Some smart or advanced dimmers need a neutral. If your box has only two wires and a ground, you likely lack a neutral. Choose a device that works without a neutral or call an electrician to rewire.
• Do not exceed the wattage rating on the device. Add the wattage of all bulbs on the circuit.

Common Wiring Colors and What They Mean

Color is a clue, not a guarantee. Always test.

• Black or red: Hot conductors
• White: Neutral in most cases. In switch loops, a white may be re-marked as hot with tape.
• Bare or green: Ground

If you see white wires on a switch without a neutral bundle, that white may be a re-tasked hot. Mark it with black tape to comply with common practice. If anything looks abnormal, stop and get help.

Troubleshooting After Replacement

If the light does not work or behaves oddly, check these items.

1. Loose or Misplaced Wires
2. • Recheck that the common is on the dark screw for three-ways.
   • Verify tight connections and correct wire strip length.
2. Bad Bulb or Fixture
3. • Test the switch by trying a different bulb or confirming the fixture works on another circuit.
3. Tripped Breaker or GFCI
4. • Reset any tripped breaker or GFCI in the same area.
4. Backstabbed Connections
5. • Backstabbed wires can be unreliable. Move them to the side screws.
5. Dimmer Compatibility
6. • Use a dimmer listed for your bulb type and total load.

Stop and call a professional if you smell burning, see scorch marks, or the breaker trips again after reset.

When to Stop and Call a Licensed Electrician in Southern NH

DIY is great for simple swaps on copper wiring in good boxes. Call a pro for any of the following.

• Aluminum wiring present. Many homes from certain eras used aluminum branch wiring. Our team performs safe aluminum-to-copper upgrades.
• Melted insulation, char, or buzzing at the panel.
• Frequent tripping, flicker on multiple circuits, or warm switch plates.
• No neutral in the box but you want a smart switch.
• Multi-gang boxes with many splices that exceed space fill.
• Wet locations or outdoor boxes needing weatherproof covers and proper ratings.

Local insight: Homes around Derry, Manchester, Nashua, and Salem range from older builds to new construction. Older homes often need grounding updates, GFCI protection in kitchens and baths, and careful labeling at the panel. Our licensed electricians provide emergency service day or night, and we offer thorough electrical safety inspections to catch early warning signs of hazards.

Why choose us when you need help:

• We have served your neighbors since 2002 and are BBB accredited with an A+ rating. These are proven trust signals.
• Our work is backed by a 2-year parts and labor warranty. Club members enjoy a 3-year warranty.
• We provide honest, upfront pricing and do not recommend work you do not need.
• We handle everything from troubleshooting and outlet repair to panel upgrades, generator installs, lighting, and full inspections.

Simple Maintenance to Prevent Future Switch Failures

• Do not exceed the bulb or fixture wattage on circuits with dimmers.
• Use quality devices. Cheap switches fail faster.
• Keep connections neat and secure under screws. Avoid backstabs.
• If a switch runs warm or crackles, shut power off and have it checked.
• Schedule an annual electrical safety inspection to catch loose terminations or aging devices before they fail.

Quick Reference: Single-Pole vs Three-Way Replacement

1. Single-Pole
2. • Two brass screws and a green ground.
   • Either hot wire can go to either brass terminal.
2. Three-Way
3. • One dark common screw, two brass travelers, and a green ground.
   • The labeled common wire must go on the dark screw. Travelers go on the brass screws.

With the right part, careful labeling, and full power-off testing, most homeowners can replace a basic switch safely. When in doubt, bring in a licensed professional who can also check panel capacity, bonding, and grounding while on site.

Special Offer

Save $25 on a fire alarm upgrade when you book electrical troubleshooting or repair. Use code: Save $25 fire alarm upgrade. Valid through 02-04-2026. Conditions apply: cannot be combined, limit one per household, valid on standard pricing, present and mention prior to job.

What Homeowners Are Saying

"This was my first time using Paul The Plumber and I was extremely happy with the whole experience... They fixed my faulty circuit breaker in no time."
–Traci D., Electrical Repair

"I’ve used Paul the Plumber twice now for electrical issues and they have been wonderful each time. They are fast, polite, knowledgeable, and very fairly priced."
–Michele S., Electrical Service

"They diagnosed the problem and fixed it in no time. Very happy and satisfied with their service. Definitely will use again."
–S. Baraket, Electrical Service

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need to shut off power at the breaker to replace a switch?

Yes. Always shut off the breaker and verify with a non-contact tester. Never rely on the switch being off. Test each wire before you touch it.

How can I tell if the light switch is bad or the fixture is the problem?

If the switch feels loose, crackles, or works only when jiggled, it is likely bad. Try another bulb and check the fixture. If the issue persists, test or replace the switch.

What if my switch has only two wires and a ground?

That is common for single-pole switches. Some smart or electronic dimmers need a neutral wire. If there is no neutral, choose a no-neutral device or call a pro.

Can I replace a three-way switch myself?

Yes, if you label the common wire before removal and follow instructions. If you are unsure which wire is common or the light still misbehaves, call a licensed electrician.

When should I call an electrician instead of doing DIY?

Call if you see aluminum wiring, scorch marks, melted insulation, repeated breaker trips, or buzzing at the panel. Also call if you lack a neutral but want a smart switch.

Conclusion

Replacing a faulty light switch is a straightforward DIY when you turn power off, label wires, and use the right device. If you prefer a pro or spot any warning signs, we can help. For homeowners near Manchester, Nashua, Derry, and Salem, we handle quick fixes and full system checks.

Use our $25 fire alarm upgrade coupon if we do the work for you.

Ready to Fix It Now?

Call Paul The Plumber at (603) 541-7986 or schedule online at https://www.paultheplumbernh.com/.

Mention “Save $25 fire alarm upgrade” when booking electrical troubleshooting or repair. Coupon must be presented prior to the job and cannot be combined. Get fast, licensed service backed by a 2-year warranty, or 3 years for club members.

About Paul The Plumber

Since 2002, Paul The Plumber has served Southern New Hampshire with licensed, insured electricians who deliver upfront pricing and courteous service. We are BBB accredited with an A+ rating and back our work with a 2-year parts and labor warranty. Club members enjoy a 3-year warranty. Get honest recommendations, fast scheduling, and clean work areas every time. We handle troubleshooting, panel upgrades, generators, lighting, and safety inspections across Derry, Manchester, Nashua, and nearby towns.